Wandering around Krakow the other day I happened to glance up at the roof line of a building I’ve passed a hundred times and noticed that it had an unusual feature. Perched on the sky line were three towers that looked for all the world like minarets, and the middle one was unmistakably a platform for the adhan (the Muslim call to prayer) with an incongruously obvious Muslim crescent perched on top.
Those are minarets or I’m a Dutchman.
Islam… in Poland? I initially assumed it was an architectural folly. The whim of some 19th century aristocrat who had spent some time in the Middle East. But the middle minaret is just too functional looking. That door is real and the balcony is no mere decoration. Why would anybody go to the trouble, unless it was built for exactly the purpose it seems to have been built for?
Of course I’ve seen the occasional Middle Eastern tourist on the streets of Krakow (and we can guess that he or she is Muslim), even the very occasional hijab, but it never occurred to me that there might be an indigenous historical population of Muslims in Poland; the place is just so overwhelmingly… well, Catholic. I did a little googling. Turns out I was wrong.
A fellow blogger pointed out a YouTube vid the other day entitled “The History of Poland in 10 minutes.” In general it’s a dangerously inane piece of romantic nationalism (complete with stirring militaristic music and pics of chaps getting their heads chopped off), but it does mention a period of Polish history known as the Warsaw Confederacy that I wasn’t aware of before. The key feature of the Warsaw Confederacy was that it guaranteed religious freedom and consequently became the chief place of refuge for Catholics, Protestants, Jews, and Muslims fleeing persecution and war in the 16th and 17th centuries. I know it’s hard to believe, but there was a time before Radio Maria. I began to wonder if there might have been an historical population of Muslims in Poland; especially in the south and east, so close to the historical and fervently defended border with the aggressive Muslim world of the past.
“Tartars” is the word. The Tartars are a Turkic people who originated somewhere in central Asia and settled all across southern Russia, the Balkans, and Turkey. By the time they arrived in what is now eastern Poland in the 14th century they were Muslims, and they have been there ever since. Poland’s Muslim Tartar’s were heavily involved in many of the nations’ critical moments from wars with the Teutonic Knights to the German invasion of 1939. The current population of Muslim Tartars in Poland is put at somewhere between three and seven thousand. Not a lot, but remarkable that they have survived with their faith intact at all. Here are some images of other Muslim Tartar mosques in Poland. Are there some similarities are am I mad?
The minaret of the Marcani Mosque in central Russia, one of the last surviving Tatar mosques in Russia. The conical roof, the iron balcony, and the spire topped with the crescent are very similar, if a little more ornate, to the Krakow example.
The new Muslim Tartar mosque in Gdansk. Again a very similar roof and balcony.
Ok maybe not this one, but this is the oldest surviving mosque in Poland.

I would love to know more about this building in Krakow.
This is a full view of the building. It’s at the corner of Długa, Pędzichów, and Filipa.
Some interesting links:
History of Tartar Muslims in Poland</a>
Loyal Muslim Tartars in Polish history
The Wikipedia treatment




Thanks for the pics! Every worth more than just knowing there are such structures. So, yeah, those are minarets and you’re not a gin-inventing-countryman.
In some text about polish history there was nice phrase about minorities in pre-war Poland – I will translate it (sloppily) “when there was break for the mass, part of the class went to the church, part to the synagogue and part to the minaret”.
This was something normal. For most of its history, Poland was inhabited by very mixed population – multitude of cultures and religions. It was WWII that changed it.
I would guess that this Gdansk mosque was built by the modern Islamic immigration (most intense during communism)
rather than Tatars.
Well Poland can be surprising. There used to be several Dutch-populated mormon-like villages in Żuławy region. Unfortunately after the WW2 communist govt threw the out on the grounds that they were “German”.
PS. plans for a new mosque in Kraków: http://krakoff.info/2007/10/23/meczet-w-centrum-krakowa/
Pawel: Not according to the source I read. The Gdansk mosque was built by the Tatar Muslim community. They are Sunni whereas the majority of recent Muslim immigrants are Shia. I would imagine the proposed mosque in Krakow will be Shia.
I should have known, the one time I really want people to tell me about something and nobody has anything to tell me
Dear Author, you did suprise me!
I have passed the very building hundreds of times and never noticed the features of the roof. My only excuse is that it is in such a busy place that a person of my height has to crane the neck for all possible dangers instead of admiring the architecture.
A friend of mine thinks that there used to be a Turkish bath in that kamienica but I am not sure. I promise to find out a little about that building but it may take some time.
That part of Krakow was developed in the 19th century; one of the architects of the era was Teodor Talowski, a man of incredible imagination and talent. He designed a few buildings in the area so maybe “the minaret” is his work too.
If you had some free time on your hands you could have a look at his “Dom pod spiewajaca zaba” in Retoryka street or “Kamienica pod pajakiem” on the corner of Karmelicka and Batorego. It is an acquired taste, I suppose, but I love what he did.
I could tell you some things. Fortunately, you had all of that covered in the links provided and I’ll add just this: as far as Kraków, the first associations with the other civilisation would probably be the arrow through the brave Polish (male) breast – hence the hejnał and the lajkonik? Or did you write this somewhere?
Poles come in all varieties
http://www.multikulti.org.pl/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=117&Itemid=1
better link: http://www.wielkiemalenarody.eu/jestem.html
Wow, talk about instant response! Thanks guys.
Jolanta: I live on Batorego (as you may have already figured) and I’ve often admired that building. I regularly point it out to A and say “That’s a really cool building, I wonder what the story behind it is!” at which she generally rolls her eyes and says “He’s off on one of his fantasy trips again.” I will track down Retoryka street soonest, if I haven’t already seen it in ignorance of its name.
The thing about the ‘Minaret’ building is that it doesn’t look like the product of an architectural mind; it’s just a very ordinary 19th century tenement that happens to have minarets on its roof.
Darth: I am, of course, very familiar with the hejnał and the lajkonik. The former can be heard quite clearly from my flat in the summer, when windows are open, and the latter from packets of crackers that go very well with cheese. That’s kind of why it was a surprise to discover that there is an historical Muslim population in Poland – kind of like finding out about a 700-year-old French village in deepest Kent
Jolanta: Ok, Retoryka, I know it well and I’ve certainly seen some interesting buildings down there. I will have to find out which one is “Dom pod spiewajaca zaba” (house under… something).
Pawel: Nice link. So Tatars are a well-known minority in Poland (I say that because they are mentioned alongside Jews, Gypsies, and Ukrainians)? I had no idea.
Hmmm, Turkish bath. Could be I suppose, but it seems an awful lot of trouble to go to just to advertise a Turkish bath (especially since typically petite Cracovians don’t look up that far). I hope it’s something more interesting.
Yes Tatars are a well known minority and Poland has a Polish-Tatar mufti.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomasz_Mi%C5%9Bkiewicz
You can see him always on TV when Poland celebrates national holidays.
Or here…
http://www.prezydent.pl/x.node?id=4542760&fotoserviceId=9500143
Gast: Thanks for the comment. The link to pictures doesn’t seem to work, all I get is a blank page. I’d be interested to see the Polish Tatar Mufti.
I bet the Mufti can be found somewhere here. The site’s has its English version, and more.
Bingo!
The building is called Dom Turecki (Turkish House) and was built around 1910 by Teodor Rayski (or Rajski) for his wife who was Muslim. Rayski went abroad after the November Rising was crushed; he took part in the Turkish-Russian war in the 1870s as an officer in the Osman Army and became a Turkish citizen.
When he returned here he at the end of the century, he brought his Muslim (Turkish or Egyptian – they probably got married in Egypt) wife with him.
The house was designed by Henryk Lamensdorf, a Polish-Jewish architect.
Rayski’s son Ludomił, an engineer and a general, had a nickname “Turek” (Turk).
The internet is a mine of information about both Rayskis but you need to know Polish a little better to find it, sorry.
The houses by Talowski in Retoryka street: the House under the Singing Frog no.1-2, no.7, no.9, no.15.
J.
PS. So there might have been a Turkish bath, albeit a private one, in the Turkish House.
Sorry, Rayski left Poland just after the January Rising, of course. At the time of the November Rising he was not born yet.
I hope my guidebook is correct as far as the numbers of Talowski’s buildings are concerned.
J.
Thanks Jolanta, you’re a star!
I will look up the Rayskis and get A to translate for me (she will be pleased!).
I still find it interesting that the Islamic features of the building are functional looking rather than just decorative, as you might expect if they were added just to please a Muslim wife. I wonder if the minaret was used to call prayers. Could there have been a small community of Muslims in that area before the first war? I will look around for more clues.
I now want to put up a post featuring all the other building in Krakow I find odd and interesting, you might have your work cut out
There is actually a plaque commemorating the life of Ludomił Rayski on the same building which I have seen before (I like looking at plaques!).
Here’s an article from the Krakow Post about the building and its minarets (in English)
http://www.krakowpost.com/articles/2008/01/25/936.html
Author, the article is very interesting indeed but … one cannot trust the Krakow Post fully. They use a lot of articles from the local press and translate them into English (I do not remember whether they usually acknowledge the source or not); however, I suspect that they do not always understand what they read and this might be the case with the Rayski family too.
I was extremely suprised once when I read in KP about the grass-roots society I am part of and our conservation work; unfortunately, the Polish KP journalist did not seem to have comprehended the nature of our voluntary work which had been explained in the Dziennik Polski quite well (the article in KP was very similar to the one in DzP). To make matters worse, the KP put a photo of our park (it was a rather sorry sight) instead of the local forest described in the text. Believe me, it makes a difference to you whether you are fighting for a fully developed eco system which is about to be destroyed by greed and ignorance or just for a patch of grass and some trees pruned to certain death.
So, be careful!
J.
Jolanta: I know what you mean about the Krakow Post. This blog is actually named after a bizarre headline I saw in that publication shortly after I arrived in July (the second post ever). However, I feel inclined to trust the bulk of this article. It ties in with the plaque to Ludomił Rayski and rings true on why the minarets might have been built. Still, it would be nice to find out more. Don’t tell anyone but I have a plan to infiltrate the building and have a surreptitious poke around
Z: Thanks for commenting. For some reason your comment ended up in the spam bin where I just found it.
Island… do these local mosques have a call to prayer at regular times? Also is the mosque close to the Orthodox or Catholic Church buildings… I know here in the Middle East if there is a Christian church there tends to be a mosque near-by…
Anyway very interesting.
[...] there similarities between / among civilisations? A Polish source here – trustworthy or not, see its bibliography – says [...]
http://www.networkeurope.org/feature/are-there-enough-muslims-in-krakow-to-warrant-an-islamic-centre
radio bit on the islamic centre in kraków. you have to remember, it’s not a mosque. of course it would be easy to think that becuase the local press in kraków has been going on about mosque building. a simeple islamic cultural centre. it does have a prayer room, but i don’t see any minarets in the plans!
the story in the krakow post about the building on dluga is realy interesting. also, i highly recommend a visit to the mosques in both bohoniki and kruszyniany up near białystok…
This is an interesting thread. Regarding posts 22 and 23, please note that Krakow Post has recently come under new ownership and I am confident that the quality of articles will improve rapidly. We are moving away completely from translating a lot of news wire stories and have made an editorial decision to use only original material going forward. All our writers are professional journalists who are very much part of the city and its life. We very much hope that the English-speaking community will give their full support to the new Krakow Post – and constructive criticism is always welcome! On a side note, please in post 21 can you change the link to the following original source:
http://www.krakowpost.com/articles/2008/01/25/936.html
As part of our bid to improve the quality of the Krakow Post, we will no longer be syndicating articles through other sites, and those links will shortly be inactive.
Kind regards,
Mark Bradshaw
Publisher
Krakow Post
Mark: Sounds encouraging. Don’t forget to check out Polandian, the ultimate English-language blog about Poland.
Link changed as per your suggestion, thanks.
[...] Légion d’honneur from Napoleon, and Virtuti Militari for defence against Russians, adopted Islam and was a Turkish field marshal, died in Ottoman [...]
island1: Thanks for that, and also the info about Polandian – it looks fascinating. In each edition of the Krakow Post we are carrying a column about English-language blogging in Poland, and we’d very much like to include Polandian in an issue soon. I’ve mentioned the blog to our Editor, and I am sure she will be in touch with the authors shortly!
Regards,
Mark
Mark: Great, I’m sure we’d be happy to participate.
“Typically petit?” I never got that impression at all. Generally average to tall height.
Hi,
I am french and I am student in master’s degree of Finance. I am going to katowice next february with the erasmus program in order to follow one semester. I am muslim and I wear a scarf. I would like to know if the pratice of islam is permitted in Poland and if there are problems for muslims?
Thanks you!
karine
Alsalam alikom all brothers and sisters
ALLHU AKBAR always and ever MINARETS of ISLAM IN EVERY PLACE .
Thank you brother for you article
Dear Sir/Madam
Salamo Aalekum,
I am from nepal and would like to come abroad so please if possible please mail me as a muslims.
Thanks
Md.shaukat ali
kathmandu
nepal
+977-9851058207
alinepali96@yahoo.com
I’ve just spotted the same on St Giles Cathedral in Edinburgh!